Hook Logo
Search

NEWS- Buck stopping: Blue law on deer draws fire

published November 23, 2006

Deer season began November 18, and for the next seven weeks, hunters can blast away in the woods-- except on Sundays. But that Sabbath-day hunting ban could soon come under some fire of its own as a new state-sponsored survey gets under way.

Dating back to just after the Civil War, when Sunday was more widely seen as the Lord's day, the shot-free Sunday was just one of the so-called "blue laws" banning many forms of commerce and recreation. Today, stores are open on Sunday, and citizens can buy a beer and enjoy other unholy activities-- but they still can't go out in the woods to hunt. 

 Surveys in 1997 and 2000 showed hunters pretty evenly divided on the Sunday ban, according to Julia Dixon, spokesperson for the the Department of Game and Inland Fisheries.

Dixon says that many residents of Tidewater and Northern Virginia, as well as people who've moved from states that allow Sunday shooting, favor repeal of this blue law, while older, rural residents are more likely to oppose it.

Opposition to Sunday hunting also comes from folks not necessarily concerned about the sanctity of the Sabbath. The ACLU, that watchdog of church/state separation, has no intention of going after the law forbidding Sunday hunting, according to its executive director, Kent Willis, even though he notes, "You probably could show a religious purpose deep in the origins of this."

State Senator Creigh Deeds is such a big supporter of the right to hunt and fish that he carried a "right-to-hunt" constitutional amendment to Virginia voters in 2000, and it passed. But allow hunting on Sundays?

"I'm a little reluctant to go down that path," says Deeds. "People in the woods with guns are inconsistent with other uses like bird watching or hiking."

For Deeds, who lives in rural, hunt-happy Bath County, "It's the one day in the week we can send the kids out without worrying about them getting shot."

When he was young, Deeds says, hunting season lasted two weeks. Now, with time for muzzle loaders and bow hunters, the season stretches from October to January. "So that one day [without hunting] is not a big deal to me," he says.

While the Bath native says he's had constituents weigh in on both sides of the issue, Deeds believes the push for Sunday hunting may be bureaucratically inspired, a reaction to a decline in sales of hunting licenses.

"They see it as a way to boost license sales and increase tourism dollars," he says.

Certainly, the survey the Game Department is taking, focusing exclusively on 5,000 hunters, may not represent the views of random citizens. And ultimately, it's up to the General Assembly to change the law.

For those who've gotta hunt on Sundays, the Game Department's Dixon suggests two alternatives: licensed game preserves where pheasants and quail are legal Sabbath targets, and raccoons-- at least up until 2am on Sunday mornings.


Current Virginia law allows deer a day of rest by banning Sunday hunting-- but that may change.
PHOTO BY HAWES SPENCER

#

                     

It is apparent by using the term “Sabbath-day hunting ban” this is more about religious objections by the author than the rights of hunters. Last time I checked, the ABC stores were closed on Sunday and the bars have closing times, where is the big outrage about that?

What about the idea of sharing our natural resources with non-hunting users just one day a week? How about a day of rest for the officers that enforce the game laws, there are only 180 of them for the whole Commonwealth? To work a 24 hours, 7 day shift it takes 5 people. There are 100 jurisdictions that need a patrol presence. If we had just 1 officer in each jurisdiction it would take 500 for basic coverage. Let alone if there were more than 1 call for service in a jurisdiction at any given time.

The Game Department already faces severe funding shortages. Virginia ranks 49 out of 50 for per-capita spending toward natural resources. I hope the proponents of Sunday hunting are willing to put their money where their mouth is!

posted by RetiredFred at 11/22/2006 1:19:42 PM

Hunters in Virginia have from October to January to hunt deer, while the rest of the year the woods is free for anyone to use any way they see fit. Then you take into consideration that most hunters only get to hunt on weekends because of work, you cut the actual number of days down considerably. Now, cut that in half because of the ban on hunting Sundays and you have around two weeks out of the year most hunters get a chance to deer hunt. To me, that doesn't seem fair. Especially when you consider that hunters pay a huge amount of money that goes toward mantaining the lands and wildlife everyone can enjoy year round when they can only enjoy hunting for such a short time. I'd like to see non-sportsmen put their money where there mouth is if it comes down to the almighty dollar. If revenue alone is what's driving the Sunday hunting push, then that means other outdoor enthusiasts aren't doing their part in supporting the outdoor programs.

posted by Cliff at 11/23/2006 2:58:03 PM

Fred, I have to disagree with you on a couple points. 1st, it should be obviuos that we already have game wardens in the field on Sundays. If we didn't there would not be any enforcement of the Sunday hunting ban. Secondly, Hunting season lasts about 3 months. Non hunters have the unrestricted use of the resources the other 9 months. Thirdly, The hunters ARE putting their money where there mouth is. The sale of hunting and fishing licenses make up the vast majority of DGIF funding. In case you haven't heard, hunting licenses went up $5 per license. That equals an increase of $15 dollars to go hunt deer with a muzzleloader and $20 if you want to bow hunt too. How much are the bird watchers kicking in? Or any other group for that matter?

posted by Joesquid at 11/27/2006 1:30:35 PM

I went as far as creating an internet petition to lift the ban on Sunday hunting in Virgina.

So far, there are well over 1500+ signatures!

http://www.petitiononline.com/shva2006/

To have such a ban still in effect in this day and age is ridiculous! Hunting has been on a decline for years, now with Playstations, X-Boxes, etc... kids are reluctant to go into the woods to hunt. That, coupled with other activies they might have on a Saturday, leave no time for them to hunt!

posted by Butch Ammon at 12/1/2006 1:21:34 PM
Your Name:
Your Email (optional):
Comment:
Image Verification:
Please type the letters above:
  *  We want vibrant debate, so please comment on this story. People say the darndest things, but if they use language stronger than "darn," if they use ethnically or racially disparaging language, or start comparing people to Hitler, they may find that we've deleted the comment without warning. A few more rules: no libel, no slander, and no lying. And please stay on the topic.



© 2002-2008 Better Publications LLC - The Hook - 100 Second Street NW - Charlottesville, VA 22902 - 434-295-8700 (fax: 434-295-8097) :Login: