COVER- ANNUAL MANUAL- I heart Charlottesville: Has our town become the Little Apple?

Dine at Ten, catch Wilco at the Charlottesville Pavillion, and cap the night at X-Lounge with a $10 martini or two. The next morning, take a class in Bikram Yoga, visit the Miller Center for a talk by Senator Ted Kennedy or George McGovern, finish up with dinner at one of the area's four-star restaurants.

Culture, culture, culture, fine dining, and diversity. Some say it's the best of times for Charlottesville. 

But then there's the ceaseless development, high real estate prices, and what many consider the loss of our small town appeal. Maybe it's the worst of times...

It  certainly was a bad time recently for a Republican Senator who used to represent Albemarle in the General Asseembly and Congress.

Is Charlottesville New Yorkifying? Can it be long before we call ourselves the "Little Apple?" Any way you slice it, the issue is ripe for debate. A few signs...

Albemarle goes Dem

Has Albemarle County adopted a New York state of mind? A look at county politics over the last 13 years shows the once-powerful Republican stronghold moving steadily to the left. In six of the last eight elections, Albemarle has joined Charlottesville in the wild blue yonder. (Although County residents voted for President George Bush by a 5.5 percent margin in 2000, and for Senator John Warner in 2002 when he faced no Democratic opponent.)

There may be no better example of the county's political shift than recently defeated former senator George Allen. When Allen ran for governor in 1993, 60 percent of Albemarle voters marked their ballots to help him defeat Democratic opponent Mary Sue Terry. But it's been downhill in Albemarle for him and other Republicans ever since.

When Allen won election to the U.S. Senate in 2000 with 52 percent of the statewide vote, Albemarle gave him an ambivalent thumbs down– 48 percent of the votes. In his 2006 defeat at the hands of Senator Jim Webb, Allen's Albemarle take shrank to just 44 percent. What gives?

"University communities tend to be heavily blue localities," says UVA professor and political pundit Larry Sabato, who accurately predicted 96 percent of the nearly 500 2006 Congressional races including Webb's upset of Allen.

"UVA has expanded its reach into Albemarle County," he says, "and this part of the Piedmont has turned a bright blue."

Sabato explains that college towns are liberal because of the high percentage of residents with graduate degrees. As the school expands, so, it seems, does the blue.

"Growth is helping to fuel this political change in Albemarle County," says Albemarle Democratic Party chair Fred Hudson.

Apparently, word of this blue-ification has penetrated the upper reaches of the Democratic party. In 2007, both Senator Barack Obama and Senator Hillary Clinton came to town to raise money for their presidential campaigns, raking in a combined $450,000.

Albemarle GOP chair Keith Drake agrees that growth is helping the Dems. He says it's the type of people moving here– particularly liberal retirees from the northeast– who have helped shift the voter demographic.

"There are a lot of folks from New York and New Jersey heading to Florida," Drake says, "and they run out of gas here."

New York state of mind, indeed.

Larry Sabato says this area is "bright blue."

Gay friendly 

Election Day 2006 was a dark one for homosexuals in the Old Dominion, when Virginians approved a consitutional amendment reiterating already existing law defining marriage as a union of one man and one woman. But here in Charlottesville– where voters rejected the amendment by the largest margin in the state, by nearly 80 percent– there was at least some reason for gays and lesbians to feel supported. 

"It's nice living in a community like this," says Mark Usry, a board member of Equality Virginia, a Gay and Lesbian nonprofit. He says local schools and governments in both Charlottesville and Albemarle respect gay rights. "We really couldn't ask for more," he says.

The east end of the Downtown Mall may never be the East Village, but Charlottesville is increasingly a place where gays and lesbians can be themselves. A website,, launched in 2005 to serve as a "portal" for gays and lesbians to connect for social activities and events, according to founder Kristi Lombard. And then there's Club 216. The late-night club proves– if nothing else– that people get along at 3am when it's the only party scene in town. On a typical weekend night, 216 gradually transforms from a primarily gay scene to one where tobacco-chewing good old boys, rappers, and a few transvestites amiably commingle. 

Club 216 plays host to all types in the wee hours.

Where there's no smoking... 

Dining options in Charlottesville run the gamut from down-home dives to French finery. While prices don't yet match New York's, diners can order the cuisine of almost any land. But international fare isn't the only Big Apple-esque element of the dining scene. If a slew of the new restaurants opening downtown are any clue, Charlottesville restaurateurs are moving in a New York direction by voluntarily banning smoking. Unlike New York City, which passed a stringent law regarding smoking in restaurants in 2003, Charlottesville government– although monopolized by Democrats– is taking a laissez-faire approach and letting the market decide.

Fleurie and Zocalo opted for non-smoking policies from the moment they opened in 2003. In the summer of '06, X-Lounge followed suit. Although he allowed smoking on its first night, owner J.F. Legault says that by night two it was verboten.

"You could really smell it the next morning," he says. 

When sleek urban eatery Maya opened on West Main in May 2007, its owners didn't even bother with allowing smoking in the first place.

"When we bought this building, we had to tear it apart because cigarette smoke had turned the whole place yellow and made it stink," says co-owner Christian Kelly. "You pour that much money into a building and you don't want it to get ruined." 

So, Maya has allowed smoking on its outdoor patio, and Kelly says that smoking customers have yet to complain to him about having to take it outside.

"People are happy to go outside and have a cigarette and come back in, or just eat on the patio," he says. "We like having a bar atmosphere, but we just never wanted to be associated with the smoky ones."

Take it outside at the X Lounge– your bad habit, that is.

Give us your tired, your poor, your huddled masses...

Apparently Lady Liberty is directing the huddled masses south. Anyone who spends a few hours observing passersby on the Downtown Mall can see that Charlottesville is now home to people who might once have been seen only in larger cities like New York. While UVA certainly draws international students and staff, this area's increasing diversity is thanks in no small part to the efforts of the International Rescue Committee, which has been resettling refugees in Charlottesville since 1998.

Committee director Susan Donovan says the goal is to bring in 150 refugees each year. The Committee assists the newcomers in assimilating, helping adults find work and homes, and helping children adapt to school. Among the countries of origin of Charlottesville refugees: Bosnia, Afghanistan, and, most recently, Somalia. 

Although 130 Somali Bantus came to Charlottesville in 2004, about half have resettled in the more arid climate in the west, she says. But the approximately 65 who remain in Charlottesville are thriving, Donovan says, mentioning with delight that one Bantu family will soon own their own home through Habitat for Humanity.

"When they got here, they'd never seen a lightbulb," she says. "Now they're going to be homeowners."

Since that first wave, Charlottesville has become home to wartime refugees from Iraq and Afghanistan, plus ever-growing populations from Iraq, Bhutan, the Congo, and especially the oppressed Karin people of Burma.

"The Karin are a race of people who were targeted for genocide by the Burmese government," explains Donovan. "They started fleeing 20 years ago when the democratic movement got started, but it was only three years ago that the United States began to accept them. Now we're resettling quite a few of them."

Refugees from Turkey dance at a party in Charlottesville.

Puttin' on the Ritz

Who needs Madison Avenue when there's the Downtown Mall? Over the last decade, the Mall and surrounding blocks have welcomed upscale boutiques such as women's clothing purveyors Eloise, Chloe, and Spring Street, as well as numerous gift and trinket shops. But nothing shows the trend toward New York exclusivity like stationery and paper goods store Caspari, which warms the hearts of the Charlottesville-centric who notice that it has headquarters in New York, but stores in just two locations: Paris, and– yes– Charlottesville. 

We're playing with the big kids now!

"New York, Paris, Charlottesville."


Gwyneth Paltrow and Sarah Jessica Parker may have picked New York's pricey pads to hang their hats, but Albemarle beckoned Sissy Spacek and Howie Long! These movers and shakers could plunk down a bundle to live anywhere they want, yet here they are on the red clay soil of Central Virginia. Joining Spacek and Long as C'ville's celebrity residents: best-selling author and baseball fan John Grisham, director Hugh Wilson, actor and former WWE superstar Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson, and that other guy. What's his name? Dave... Dave something? Oh, yeah, you mean that guy who bartended at Miller's?

Grisham picks Charlottesville.

Festivals galore

New York may be the festival capital of the world, but Charlottesville has steadily increased its reputation for world-class festivities like the Festival of the Photograph, Virginia Festival of the Book, the Virginia Film Festival. Every year, authors and auteurs descend on the city, drawing thousands of fans and fawning groupies from around the country.

In March, they pore over pages of every type of book imaginable, while authors like Malcolm Gladwell and Tony Horwitz give readings and discuss their works. This year's Festival will mark the 15th anniversary of the shindig.

In June, droves of shutter-happy denizens descended on the Downtown Mall to hear and see some of the best and most celebrated photographers in the world at the Festival of the Photograph.

In October, Charlottesville is the place for premieres– this year, The Savages and The Diving Bell and the Butterfly were big hits at the Virginia Film Festival after wowing festival crowds in Telluride, Toronto, and yes, New York, and eventually, Academy Award voters.

Warrentonian Robert Duvall added star power to a recent festival's opening night gala.


Crowds fill auditoriums for the Virginia Festival of the Book.

Condo craze

Charlottesville has a long way to go before it can say it's competing with New York real estate prices, but the recent condo craze spawned a few places so luxurious– and so expensive– that it seems impossible they aren't in mid-town Manhattan. Take the Holsinger, built in 2005 on Water Street next to the C&O restaurant. Several of the larger penthouse units sold for over $1 million last year, while smaller units in the building easily topped half a million– and that's not counting monthly condo fees.

More recently, The Randolph two blocks away at the corner of 10th and Market has given The H a run for its money. Units there equal the Holsinger's prices, and there are still some available!

Million dollar condos have arrived.

The Coran

New York has the Donald. Charlottesville has the Coran. Indeed, if there's one person in town who's singlehandedly driving urbanization, it may be Dave Matthews Band manager Coran Capshaw, who keeps the Charlottesville/New York connection alive in seemingly countless ways: ATO Records, the music label Capshaw co-founded with Dave Matthews, has offices in Crozet and... New York. Another Capshaw project includes the Charlottesville Pavilion, which regularly brings acts once considered too big for our a little central-Virginia burg. And he's currently at work modernizing the Jefferson Theater to be yet another music mecca.

Capshaw's real estate empire stretches from the Downtown Mall to an 89-acre parcel off Fifth Street Extended and out to Crozet. And his restaurants bespeak a certain urban, New York-ish, vibe: Blue Light Grill, Mas tapas bar, Mono Loco, and sushi bar Ten, which just hosted Sen. Barack Obama for an October 2007 fundraiser for his presidential campaign. Make no mistake, in the Coran's eyes, nothing's too chic for Charlottesville.

The Coran is to Charlottesville as the Donald is to New York.

On the other hand...

New York, Schmoo York! Charlottesville isn't the Big Apple, the little apple, not even a crab apple, according to longtime resident and Live Arts director John Gibson. He objects to the tendency to compare Charlottesville to any other place, but particularly to a big city.

"The urban experience as I know it," says Gibson, "has to do with a variety of cultures and ethnicities coexisting."

Although that variety has increased locally, Charlottesville has a long way to go before we'll be urban by that definition, says Gibson, the artistic director at Live Arts, a theatrical company.

Gibson pins his hopes for diversity on two entities: UVA and the International Rescue Committee, the former which grows each year and the latter which brings in 150 refugees from around the globe each year. 

Another reason Charlottesville isn't truly urban: "a lack of true economic diversity," he says, because the poor are being systematically pushed out of town by rising real estate costs. 

The result, says Gibson, is that the people who are left are "very affluent," and that universal affluence harms the city in subtle ways. Great art, for instance, often comes from the suffering poor class intermingling with those of great wealth. 

But that's not happening here.

"There seems to be little of the discomfort that comes from wildly variant classes rubbing up against one another," he says.

Gibson's certainly not wishing poverty on anyone; he's simply pointing out the ways in which he believes Charlottesville is not– and will never be– like New York.

That said, Gibson admits there's nowhere he'd rather live, and he sings the praises of all that Charlottesville does offer– from cultural events to shopping to natural beauty and history.

"No, we're not an urban center, but what a great alternative we are," he says. "Can we not be content being a little town with all of these wildly wonderful amenities? Why do we have to model ourselves on New York? Why can't we be a village with an atittude that's not metropolitan but cosmopolitan. 

"Let's not look to the cities for a model, let's look to the world as a model."

John Gibson sees affluenza (but he doesn't call it that)



Here we go again with the globalist propaganda. It just never ends.

If C-ville were REALLY so much like NYC, our local rags wouldn't be writing cover stories like this but instead would have more important things to cover.

NYC doesn't have DMB, so in your face, Dave!

and wow....another story about Charlottesville that mentions Dave Matthews and Coran Capshaw. color me shocked.

let's all give ourselves a pat on the back. i feel good about it!

Plus our music scene is hot. NYC doesn't have DMB or Six Day Bender, Dave!

Unfortunately, I can name one thing New York has that we don't (and seemingly never will): a championship football team. Good-bye, Al. Hit the lights when you're done.

I agree with both of Dave's comments above. Everyone needs to face the facts: Charlottesville is nothing but a college town where the University is in full control. So what if we have a few celebrities who live in the area? Celebrities have to live somewhere too and that is not a reason to brag about how great of a city/town this is. A lot of the restaurants are overpriced with below quality food. I have to admit that there are some great concerts that come to area but the ticket prices keep people from attending. Personally, I believe the bragging about the Dave Matthews Band being from the area needs to stop because it gone on for the past decade and it is time to find something new. I have only lived here for the past two years and I cannot wait to move next year. One last point: Charlottesville is nothing like New York City.

I live in a small town in South Carolina. We have restaurants and a restored cinema along with bowling alley and other amenities. We're just like Charlotte! Kidding aside. New York City has 9 million people. More than twice the population of South Carolina. I'm not sure, but I think Charlottesville and surrounding area is less than 1 million. For Charlottesville to reach NYC status, it'd take 100 years of what is currently going on. But it never will, because NYC is an immigrant port and haven. There is a long history of migration and jobs in that area. Charlottesville is nowhere near this type of atmosphere and will only attract more of the same, those with money to waste on overpriced housing and dining.

A more appropriate comparison would be Jackson Hole, WY, or San Francisco, where regular working-class and middle-class people and their families cannot afford to live, and where the rich come to work and play and retire. Restaurants, music, and the like, only matter to people when they can afford to enjoy them.

Alas, one particular way in which Charlottesville is becoming less like NY is that we are losing the natural beauty of it's biggest green space to an expressway and other development.

MUSIC SCENE??? What music scene?

Courtney, You must be embarrassed to write crap like that. Please do us all a favor and make it stop.

I have lived here for years and love the place. (I and many other will not be sad to see Jeff, who posted above, leave us in peace.) To compare this great little town to NYC, which I also happen to like a lot, is just so asinine that it isn't even really amusing.